Official Luthiers Forum!

Having concentrated only on classical guitars before, this was my first attempt at a steel string.

Soundboard: Blonde western red cedar (from Doug Kleist)
Back/Sides: Cocobolo (from Hibdon Hardwood)
Bindings: Bloodwood (from the Zootman)
Bridge: Madagascar rosewood (from LMI)
Finish: French polished shellac

Sound: As a classical player, I really like this steel string guitar because it has what attracts me to a nice classical—very good focus and responsiveness with a particularly good first string. Its projection and sustain are impressive, and it has nice balance, large dynamic range, and even transition across the strings. The voice is rich and smooth with just enough edge.

Thanks to: The OLF community for sharing priceless experience and wisdom; Michael Payne for the OLF SJ plans; John Mayes for his voicing videos which provided a solid conceptual framework for the voicing of my first steel string top; Tom Rein at Hibdon for selecting the perfect sides to match the back; and the above OLF sponsors for providing excellent materials.








__________________
Gary L
Previously Philadelphia, PA, now Wayne NJ

Dang, Gary, that's outstanding!!!!!!! Beautiful work and beautiful instrument. That has as much fine detail work as I've ever seen. Just magnificient!!

Ron

_________________
OLD MAN formerly (and formally) known as:

Ron Wisdom

Somewhere in the middle of Arkansas......

Gary, that is really gorgeous.  You have delivered a steel string with classic beauty.   Nice look and apparently sound, from what you say.

_________________
Waddy

Photobucket Build Album Library

Sound Clips of most of my guitars

Gorgeous
Man do you do some fine work. Your miters look perfect.
That wood combo was on my 1st guitar. A fantastic sounding combination

_________________
Andy Z.
http://www.lazydogguitars.com

outstanding work!

_________________
Peter M.
Cornerstone Guitars
http://www.cornerstoneukes.com

Clean machine! Beautiful wood combinations and details all around, the bloodwood looks terrific against the coco. What is the red line in the purfling? Is the headstock V-jointed?

_________________
Rian Gitar og Mandolin

I looked at this again, and I want to add that the photos are very nice and really do the instrument justice. I also noticed what looks like recessed shelves in the wall behind the bench in the first picture, with hand planes and...what else? Do you have more pictures of this (in another thread perhaps), I assume it is your shop. It looks tidy for sure!

_________________
Rian Gitar og Mandolin

Great wood combination. The classical guitar influence really shows and it looks terrific - hope you will post more steel strings in the future.

                      Peace, Paul

beautiful guitar and great craftsmanship too!

_________________
Reguards,

Ken H

Stunning Gary. Absolutely stunning! I love the purfling with this wood combo and a supper FP finish.

I echo all the above compliments. Having said that, I'd like to add: "You did that Cocobolo justice!" Woohoo, I know you are pleased.... more more.....

_________________
http://www.dickeyguitars.com

Wow, that is beautiful.

I would be interested in hearing how you backstrapped and including purfling lines around the volute. I have seen that done before and really think it is a nice look.

_________________
Brock Poling
Columbus, Ohio
http://www.polingguitars.com

I love the headstock details. You should be proud, this is a fantastic guitar.

Coming from a classical brackground did you find this build easier or harder?

_________________
Matt Jacobs

"Don't tase me bro"

This is a beautiful guitar Gary!

I really like the design choices you've made, and I love the purf around the headstock... it looks perfectly mitered. Did you make the Purfling?   Is it bloodwood?

And yes, I'd too would like to know more about how your volute is done.

Long

_________________
"No man ever steps in the same river twice, for it's not the same river and he's not the same man.” -Heraclitus of Ephesus

Gary,

Your work is impeccable! I love everything about this guitar from the wood
choices to the execution of the purfling work. Bravo!

_________________
Christopher C. Cordle
North Muskegon, MI

http://www.yardsaleunderwear.com
http://www.facebook.com/christopher.cordle

Dude...freak!   

_________________
Eagles may soar, but weasels don't get sucked into jet engines.

Great stuff!  Terrific execution, particularly the headstock. Wonderful colour.

_________________
Dave
Milton, ON

Good looking guitar! Very nice work!

_________________
Billy Dean Thomas
Covina, CA

"Multi famam, conscientiam, pauci verentur."
(Many fear their reputation, few their conscience)

Very fine work! Great mitres and neat "L" logo.
It sounds like this one turned out excellant for you soundwise. I'm working on an SJ now and I hope it turns out half as nice as this.

_________________
Anderson Guitars
Clearwater,Fl. 33755

Man, Gary, that is mighty fine! Beautiful work. It looks like you carved and profiled your neck more to classical specs than steel string. True?

Absolutely delicious!
And the back of the peghead is particularly tasty.

Steve

_________________
From Nacogdoches...the oldest town in Texas.

http://www.stephenkinnaird.com

Thanks to everyone for the extremely kind words. Here are answers to questions.

To Brock and Bob:
The style for the back of the head was inspired by Jim Olson’s. I tried to re-create the look of his, but in my case, the head has a scarf joint with what I would call a “faux V-joint” volute.

I cut my head with a flush-trim bit around an acrylic template. This is done in an open-ended routing box where the head and template are bolted to a stage below that has threaded inserts.


Using the same router box and head template, I shape the front and back head plates, only this time, I use a rabbeting bit to cut the plates slightly smaller than the head to allow for the width of the binding and purfs. Here, the head plate and routing template are bolted through holes positioned where the tuner posts will eventually go. The “V” cut-out and the adjacent curves at the bottom of the plate are cut on the band saw. Left: (koa for another SJ), Right: cocobolo.


The binding and purfs are added directly to the head plate and surface sanded before gluing to the head. The binding has a little extra thickness to overhang the edge of the head, but will be later scraped flush to the head when glued.


Now back to the neck and head.... Using the router box, the head is flipped over with the back of the head facing up, and the back of the head is reduced to final thickness above the widest part of the head and to 3 mm thicker below this point to allow the hand carving of a smooth ramp to the end of the head. Here you can see it as a small step just in front of the volute's vertex. Providing the additional 3 mm for the ramp is very important; otherwise, the bottom end of the head plate will likely end up somewhere below the thickest point on the back of the neck—not a good look. The actual amount for extra thickness will depend on your desired head angle (14 degrees), head thickness (11 mm thick head + 2.5 mm thick back plate), and neck thickness at the nut (21 mm). During these thickness-reducing steps with the router, I roughly leave behind a triangular peninsula that will become the volute.


Now comes the fitting of the “V” cut-out in the head plate to the volute. Positioning the plate above the head with V cut-out above the volute peninsula, I trace the V onto the head and cut it with a razor saw and chisel. With the fit perfect, I glue the plate to the head. This fitting step is a little time-consuming, but for my first attempt, it worked well. I hope to develop a template routing system in the future.



An aside: The router box idea turned out to be very handy. I used it to rout the truss rod and carbon fiber rod slots by adding runners to the router platform. I found that fur screws coming into the box at a downward angle made good skewers to hold down the neck. I also made a similar box to shape my bridges (like shaping the head above) and to slot them (with the bridge blank mounted in the box at an angle for compensation and the runners attached to the router platform).


To Arnt:
The red purfling is rust-colored veneer from LMI.
The head is attached with a scarf joint as described above.
More shop pics are archived somewhere in a “Show me your shop” thread. Sadly, I just moved and now I have to rebuild the shop. It was a beautiful shop. Ah, the glory that was Rome.

To Matt:
My impression is that it was easier for me to produce a fine sounding steel string guitar than a classical. The voicing process (thanks again to John Mayes) was much more intuitive, and the changes were very apparent as it progressed through brace carving. I’m convinced that this is due to fact that braces start and end far more massive than on classicals, so there is plenty of room for gradual improvement during voicing. On classicals, one teeters on a knife edge between superb and awful.

In terms of time (not counting methods development and making jigs), I spent 165 hours on this steel string, building in a batch of two (i.e. 330 hours for two SJ’s--pics of the Carpathian and Koa cutaway coming soon!). My classicals take 125-140 hours. Why more time for steel strings? It’s all the #$%@$% additional binding, purfling, volutes, extra head plates, electronics, and fret markers that are expected on steel string instruments! Most classical players adhere to tradition and don’t want that on their guitars. The only thing that takes more time on a classical is a handmade rosette.

I’m really glad that I built the steel strings. It opened up a whole new world of techniques and concepts to me that will greatly improve my classicals.

To Bob:
Around the back of the head is bloodwood from (RC Tonewoods) with black and white fiber purflings.

To Carlton:
Yes, I shaped the neck so that I could comfortably move between it and a classical. It is 48 mm at the nut, which is midway between standard steel strings and classicals. The back of the neck is shaped like many classicals—somewhat flat with the thickest portion slightly on the bass side.

Nice build, and good answers too.  The whole enchilada!

_________________
Waddy

Photobucket Build Album Library

Sound Clips of most of my guitars

Thanks Gary. That's a really nice show-and-tell. Great job of problem solving to make your concept work so beautifully. You know, if you have a network of classical players in your area, you might find that others would like a steel string that "feels" right, too. Could be a niche market that no one else is addressing.