Official Luthiers Forum! :: View topic - Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement

What kind of guitars?

Usually on electrics and acoustics, the trussrod do the job, and on classical you don't even need reinforcement if you use a great Qsawn neck without runout.

I don't rienforce anything per se'. I normally laminate necks, if I have a flat sawn neck blank, I will spit it and re-glue it quarter sawn, or just make a 5 piece neck. Either way putting any sort of laminations together is stronger than the original, so it is sort of rienforcing it. I generally have to use the 2-way truss rod to get some relief in the 5 piece necks. I think unless it is a real weak wood, it would probably be ok without reinforcement, but it wouldn't hurt to add it.

I run parallel 1/4" carbon fiber rods in ALL my necks. Period. I like it

Chris

Mustang_jt wrote:

I was thinking of doing this with some mahogany I have. How would you say the appearance of it is after? Can you see seems?

Rusty wrote:

Mustang_jt wrote:

I was thinking of doing this with some mahogany I have. How would you say the appearance of it is after? Can you see seems?

If you have a good joint then you really can't even see it unless you look really close. The line is running with the grain so it just looks like a grain line if you can see it at all.
I am trying to remember where I read about it, but I have seen people take even quarter sawn neck wood and split it 3 ways and flip the middle section around to add stability. I do know that most of Carvin's koa and walnut necks are all 2 piece. I have a few walnut neck blanks glued up right now all 2 piece. I can't see the line from more than a foot away. I suspect that because the trees are so small that they only cut them flat sawn as I have only seen walnut that way (limited wood suppliers though).

I run parallel 1/4" carbon fiber rods in ALL my necks. Period. I like it

Chris

Author:	Rusty [ Tue Oct 12, 2010 8:21 pm ]
Post subject:	Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
I have been reinforcing my necks that are rift sawn with carbonfiber rods for extra stiffness. I am now just starting to use quartersawn wood for my set neck guitars and was curious to see what you guys do. Reinforce or not??

Author:	Ti-Roux [ Tue Oct 12, 2010 8:26 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
What kind of guitars? Usually on electrics and acoustics, the trussrod do the job, and on classical you don't even need reinforcement if you use a great Qsawn neck without runout.

Author:	Rusty [ Tue Oct 12, 2010 8:47 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
Ti-Roux wrote: What kind of guitars? Usually on electrics and acoustics, the trussrod do the job, and on classical you don't even need reinforcement if you use a great Qsawn neck without runout. My set neck electrics.

Author:	Mustang_jt [ Tue Oct 12, 2010 8:52 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
I don't rienforce anything per se'. I normally laminate necks, if I have a flat sawn neck blank, I will spit it and re-glue it quarter sawn, or just make a 5 piece neck. Either way putting any sort of laminations together is stronger than the original, so it is sort of rienforcing it. I generally have to use the 2-way truss rod to get some relief in the 5 piece necks. I think unless it is a real weak wood, it would probably be ok without reinforcement, but it wouldn't hurt to add it.

Author:	Rusty [ Tue Oct 12, 2010 9:01 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
Mustang_jt wrote: I don't rienforce anything per se'. I normally laminate necks, if I have a flat sawn neck blank, I will spit it and re-glue it quarter sawn, or just make a 5 piece neck. Either way putting any sort of laminations together is stronger than the original, so it is sort of rienforcing it. I generally have to use the 2-way truss rod to get some relief in the 5 piece necks. I think unless it is a real weak wood, it would probably be ok without reinforcement, but it wouldn't hurt to add it. I was thinking of doing this with some mahogany I have. How would you say the appearance of it is after? Can you see seems?

Official Luthiers Forum! http://w-ww.luthiersforum.com/forum/

Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement http://w-ww.luthiersforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10123&t=29461	Page 1 of 1

Author:	Rusty [ Tue Oct 12, 2010 9:02 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
Mustang_jt wrote: I don't rienforce anything per se'. I normally laminate necks, if I have a flat sawn neck blank, I will spit it and re-glue it quarter sawn, or just make a 5 piece neck. Either way putting any sort of laminations together is stronger than the original, so it is sort of rienforcing it. I generally have to use the 2-way truss rod to get some relief in the 5 piece necks. I think unless it is a real weak wood, it would probably be ok without reinforcement, but it wouldn't hurt to add it. I was thinking of doing this with some mahogany I have. How would you say the appearance of it is after? Can you see seems?

Author:	Ti-Roux [ Tue Oct 12, 2010 9:45 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
verhoevenc wrote: I run parallel 1/4" carbon fiber rods in ALL my necks. Period. I like it Chris Do you also put a truss rod, or just a CF rod?

Author:	Mustang_jt [ Wed Oct 13, 2010 9:13 am ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
Rusty wrote: Mustang_jt wrote: I don't rienforce anything per se'. I normally laminate necks, if I have a flat sawn neck blank, I will spit it and re-glue it quarter sawn, or just make a 5 piece neck. Either way putting any sort of laminations together is stronger than the original, so it is sort of rienforcing it. I generally have to use the 2-way truss rod to get some relief in the 5 piece necks. I think unless it is a real weak wood, it would probably be ok without reinforcement, but it wouldn't hurt to add it. I was thinking of doing this with some mahogany I have. How would you say the appearance of it is after? Can you see seems? If you have a good joint then you really can't even see it unless you look really close. The line is running with the grain so it just looks like a grain line if you can see it at all. I am trying to remember where I read about it, but I have seen people take even quarter sawn neck wood and split it 3 ways and flip the middle section around to add stability. I do know that most of Carvin's koa and walnut necks are all 2 piece. I have a few walnut neck blanks glued up right now all 2 piece. I can't see the line from more than a foot away. I suspect that because the trees are so small that they only cut them flat sawn as I have only seen walnut that way (limited wood suppliers though).

Author:	Rusty [ Wed Oct 13, 2010 1:58 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
Mustang_jt wrote: Rusty wrote: Mustang_jt wrote: I don't rienforce anything per se'. I normally laminate necks, if I have a flat sawn neck blank, I will spit it and re-glue it quarter sawn, or just make a 5 piece neck. Either way putting any sort of laminations together is stronger than the original, so it is sort of rienforcing it. I generally have to use the 2-way truss rod to get some relief in the 5 piece necks. I think unless it is a real weak wood, it would probably be ok without reinforcement, but it wouldn't hurt to add it. I was thinking of doing this with some mahogany I have. How would you say the appearance of it is after? Can you see seems? If you have a good joint then you really can't even see it unless you look really close. The line is running with the grain so it just looks like a grain line if you can see it at all. I am trying to remember where I read about it, but I have seen people take even quarter sawn neck wood and split it 3 ways and flip the middle section around to add stability. I do know that most of Carvin's koa and walnut necks are all 2 piece. I have a few walnut neck blanks glued up right now all 2 piece. I can't see the line from more than a foot away. I suspect that because the trees are so small that they only cut them flat sawn as I have only seen walnut that way (limited wood suppliers though). Good to know. Thanks for the info. I'll have to do this to make use of the wood I have.

Author:	Jebarri [ Wed Oct 13, 2010 9:00 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
So far I have just used single piece quarter sawn walnut with the lmi dual action truss rod, haven't had any problems yet. verhoevenc wrote: I run parallel 1/4" carbon fiber rods in ALL my necks. Period. I like it Chris Do you just sandwich the truss rod with carbon fiber rods or put them in separate channels?

Author:	Brett L Faust [ Fri Oct 15, 2010 8:47 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Quartersawn Neck Reinforcement
I tend to go with no CF in my guitars, I usually favor a thick asymmetric neck profile though. I have built many guitar necks with CF in them for other folks who prefer a very thin profile. The biggest myth is that CF will keep a wood neck stable,as in not let it twist. WRONG, but it will help keep it from bowing. It will also reduce dead spots especially in basses and I usually will not build a bass without CF.

Page 1 of 1	All times are UTC - 5 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/