Official Luthiers Forum! http://w-ww.luthiersforum.com/forum/ |
|
Strat pickups - wires too short http://w-ww.luthiersforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10123&t=42492 |
Page 1 of 2 |
Author: | dzsmith [ Sun Jan 19, 2014 10:55 am ] |
Post subject: | Strat pickups - wires too short |
I bought neck and bridge vintage wound Strat pickups from GFS to use in a Tele body. The wires are too short to reach the control plate. The pickups have two discrete wires. Can I snip the wires near the pickup and solder them to a shielded cable, or is it best to solder discrete wires to lengthen them? Thanks, Dan |
Author: | dzsmith [ Sun Jan 19, 2014 11:55 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Thanks Chris! |
Author: | the Padma [ Sun Jan 19, 2014 12:17 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Das too much soldering arround...just get ?admas Special Handy Dandy Wire Stretcher. 20 bucks, in an envelop C/o dis here web site. and Lance will send it right on out to you. |
Author: | dzsmith [ Sun Jan 19, 2014 5:41 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
the Padma wrote: Das too much soldering arround...just get ?admas Special Handy Dandy Wire Stretcher. 20 bucks, in an envelop C/o dis here web site. and Lance will send it right on out to you. Thanks Padma! Do you take wooden nickels? |
Author: | twick [ Sun Jan 19, 2014 9:46 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Ouch. Was that really necessary? |
Author: | nyazzip [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 1:41 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
that 43-44 gauge pickup wire is fine as a hair, and equally easy to break....i'd be inclined to leave the bobbin contacts alone, and splice further on down the line. if you break the bobbin wire, the pickup is toast, until you unwind a loop or two, scrape the laquer off the wire with fine sandpaper, and manage to resolder....but i'm not sure what you mean by discrete wire. coax? |
Author: | nyazzip [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 1:58 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Quote: Ouch. Was that really necessary? maybe not necessary, but apropos. ...nor am i innocent myself; those who continually act the fool/are combative/demeaning/or just plain full of $hi7 deserve a smackdown from time to time |
Author: | the Padma [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 2:14 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Yo, nyassip and Chris Me has hammered well over 12,000 frets in me life, and not on some assembly line ether. Me is sure you can calculate how many builds that is. Now until both of you can show pics of your first dozen builds, me most humbly suggest you both shut yer mouth and show some respect to those of us who can, do, and have earned the right to act and express how we chose. So there you go dudes, thats your smack down. blessings non the less Padma |
Author: | nyazzip [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 2:41 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
i've encountered people who have been doing things for 20-30 years, and yet they still do a mediocre job, and can't even answer basic questions about the "why" and "what" about their produce. experience(and age) are not default worship cues, in my book- not all old people are wise, i assure you. not all of the young are stupid, either. |
Author: | the Padma [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 2:53 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
. Show pics or shut up. |
Author: | B. Howard [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 7:34 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Hey Padma, just some advice which you can take for what it's worth......if you want people to take you serious as a craftsman and a mentor, you may want to consider improving your communication skills.......it's hard to take anything serious when it's communicated in a way that shows the presenter to be of the same mental and verbal skill level as the cookie monster from sesame street. I mean no offense, but that's an honest observation from someone who does not really know you.....that is how you appear to a lot of us, just a buffoon here for comic relief and not to be taken seriously......JS. |
Author: | Sandywood [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 9:01 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
nyazzip wrote: that 43-44 gauge pickup wire is fine as a hair, and equally easy to break....i'd be inclined to leave the bobbin contacts alone, and splice further on down the line. if you break the bobbin wire, the pickup is toast, until you unwind a loop or two, scrape the laquer off the wire with fine sandpaper, and manage to resolder....but i'm not sure what you mean by discrete wire. coax? I agree. If one can't rewind pickups or not prepared to replace them it's best to stay away from the eyelets/bobbin wires. |
Author: | theguitarwhisperer [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 10:01 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
verhoevenc wrote: The manner in which most of these pickups are made they wrap the copper wire around the eyelet several times and then solder, and attach the leads. I seriously doubt it'll come unwrapped in the changing of a single lead. The only other potential harm I see coming here is if he sits on the eyelet way too long with an overheated iron. Those winding threads are thin and I have seen heat eat through them... but it took a bit. My advice: Concentrate on just removing and replacing the lead, don't fret about the windings. Chris Those GFS pickups are pretty shoddily made. I'd splice some wires first before messing with the bobbin. |
Author: | Sandywood [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 10:32 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
verhoevenc wrote: The manner in which most of these pickups are made they wrap the copper wire around the eyelet several times and then solder, and attach the leads. I seriously doubt it'll come unwrapped in the changing of a single lead. The only other potential harm I see coming here is if he sits on the eyelet way too long with an overheated iron. Those winding threads are thin and I have seen heat eat through them... but it took a bit. My advice: Concentrate on just removing and replacing the lead, don't fret about the windings. Chris The wraps on the eyelets don't mean a thing. They are there to help keep the wire taut while making them. One is still dealing with a single wire at the eyelets. If the lead wire is damaged one has a shot at soldering more coil wire to it, if they have some, and if it doesn't get broke off at the coil-your sure not going to get more lead wire than whats exposed. If the end lead breaks then it may be possible to unwrap some...if it's been potted then more trouble to deal with... Just not worth the risk if one isn't prepared to rewind or replace the pups. Those that want to push their luck...go for it. |
Author: | the Padma [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 12:04 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
. Pre-emptor Normaly me respond to this type of comment in PM. However since it was posted in open forum, me responding in kind. B. Howard wrote: Hey Padma, just some advice which you can take for what it's worth......if you want people to take you serious as a craftsman and a mentor, you may want to consider improving your communication skills.......it's hard to take anything serious when it's communicated in a way that shows the presenter to be of the same mental and verbal skill level as the cookie monster from sesame street. I mean no offense, but that's an honest observation from someone who does not really know you.....that is how you appear to a lot of us, just a buffoon here for comic relief and not to be taken seriously......JS. Yo Brian dude, me choice of verbage be me choice... so me ask, who the $HIT are you to pass judgment on me communication skills and offer me advise on my being? Hmmm? You god or sumpthin? Non the less, regarding me Englishes....did you know that the late grate u s of de a don't gotts no official legal language? Thats right. Perhaps maybe thats why they hazzing so much problem communicatin with the rest of the world. Me, well me country gots 2 official languages and me is quite fluent in both plus a few others. Ya comic relief, right on Brian....you gets it...give the man a ceegar. Unfortunately you not yet be a member of dis here forum when ?adma joined and right up front in me very first thread, declared me intent, purposed and methodology of posting me communications with the brotheren. Sorry you missed that thread. Listen up dude...your highly regarded on forum as a very knowledgeable builder...even learned a thing or two meself reading yer posts. Now you and me both know, well maybe you don't know, but all of me build threads have off the wall views or hits...not to shabby for someone who be not taken seriously eh. And yours? Right! Seems its getting time for Padma to post another build thread. See Brain, when ever me hazzent posted for a while me starts getting love PMs from me followers, and hate mail from the newbee members who don't know shift from putty, and then there is the unsolicited, self invited, "holier than thou arn't" type messages that start like yours did with "just some advice " But at least they have the courtesy to insert the word 'friendly'. Brian, your a highly respected and very knowledgeable builder in me eyes. Me friendly suggestion to you is really simple ~ mind your own buisness, unless of course, we is talking about loofering, then me would be most interested in reading what you be laying down. blessings ?adma |
Author: | theguitarwhisperer [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 5:59 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
The problem isn't really the wire in this case, it's the plastic GFS bobbin that melts really easily unless you have a pointed solder tip at the right temp. Easy enough to do if you've done a few or want to experiment and don't mind buying a few pickups, but it sounds like the guy bought a used GFS to save money an simply wants to lengthen the wires. The least risky and most reliable way would be to simply splice the wires longer where they're at, which is really what his question was. Frankly it's NOT controversial! And Padma's builds are usually the most interesting ones on here! I've thought many times about posting ANOTHER carved-top set-neck wooden-binding solid body electric to add to the multitudes of existing builds here and on other forums, but frankly, as flawless and nice as my execution is, it wouldn't really add anything that other luthiers haven't already re-made and reposted as if they were the first ones to ever do it before. When I'm doing stuff truly as artistic and requiring of extra-super luthier skills as Duh Padma, THEN I'll start denigrating and insulting other luthiers who have done nothing more than post an off the wall comment on a simple topic. If all I'm doing is posting builds and instructional videos of something that's already been done a hundred times before me, then I'll try to be polite and ignore people that annoy me. Really, how small is it if you have to whip out and wave it around on THIS topic? |
Author: | dzsmith [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:38 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Yes, the bobbins are plastic - looks like molded styrene. I'm not sure I can re-solder wires without melting the bobbin. The pickups are new - I'm putting them into a Tele body and the wires are too short to reach the control plate. My question should have been more specific: I want to splice a shielded cable rather than splice single wires. Will this adversely affect the pickup performance? I have minimal experience using single-coils. Sorry for the confusion, Dan |
Author: | theguitarwhisperer [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 6:54 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
The shielded wire will have minimal, if any effect, reducing noise, which is why most single coils don't get them. You should be fine splicing new 22gauge stranded wire to the ends of whatever you have., Humbuckers typically get shielded wire because of the design, and the braided outside shield is soldered to the metal chassis as well as the final ground lead off the coil, and the chassis is usually soldered to a metal cover, and the whole contraption is thought to provide some shielding as well as hum-cancelling capabilities. Your typical single coil has NONE of that, and so doesn't require shielded cable, unless you just want some for comfort And the way you asked the question has NOTHING to do with any of the responses you've read beyond helpful info. |
Author: | dzsmith [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 7:23 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Thanks Whisperer. I would enjoy seeing posted pictures of your builds. I get inspired seeing the great builds here, and sometimes I'll see details and methods to help with my learning. Dan |
Author: | theguitarwhisperer [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 7:35 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
Dan I lived in Texas for many years and miss the heck out of it. I'd like to go back some day. My wife doesn't share that desire so much, as the Florida winters are so mild. (Especially THIS year, comparatively!). I know, off topic. I'm sure someone will be along shortly to administer the scourging. |
Author: | the Padma [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 7:39 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
theguitarwhisperer wrote: .... Padma's builds are usually the most interesting ones on here!.... When I'm doing stuff truly as artistic and requiring of extra-super luthier skills as Duh Padma, THEN I'll start denigrating and insulting other luthiers who have done nothing more than post an off the wall comment on a simple topic. If all I'm doing is posting builds and instructional videos of something that's already been done a hundred times before me, then I'll try to be polite and ignore people that annoy me. Really, how small is it if you have to whip out and wave it around on THIS topic? Well I, me, and ?admas humbleness is honoured by your flattery of me unbounded ego. And we all know what flattery begets. Thank you. May your camel never wander. blessings ?adma |
Author: | Sandywood [ Mon Jan 20, 2014 9:06 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
verhoevenc wrote: I get the concept Sandy, I build pickups so I'm pretty familiar with them. Yes, it's a single wire leaving the eyelet going into the coil. However, standard practice is to then wrap the wire around the eyelet a couple times; it's very easy to see if they did it. Because this is wrapped, the concept of it slipping away and making it impossible to re-attach is not a worry. IMO, you'd have to TRY to screw this up... And for those afraid of break the strand going from the eyelet to the coil it's on the other side of the flatwork from where you're soldering, moving the iron around, etc. Look, COULD you break it, sure. But IMO it's much more likely you won't. And without trying, you'll never know for the future if you're capable. Give it a go. It's really not that hard at all. Chris Then you must agree that if things go south, and a very real possibility, then one must be prepared to rewind or replace. Simple. And if you wind then the you should know that the wraps coming unwrapped is not the issue at all. It's a novice melting the single lead wire(s). You recommend to take a chance... I recommend extending the wires and stay away from a melt-down if one can't rewind or not prepared to replace them. nuff said. still trying to learn how to type |
Author: | RTurner [ Tue Jan 21, 2014 12:19 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
If you don't have the chops nor correct soldering gear to rewire a Strat-style pickup...no matter what the bobbin is made of...and/or you can't afford to pay for screwing stuff up in the learning process, you probably shouldn't be messing with this stuff. Most...or all of us who are pros have learned by doing, and that means daring to do what we have not done before...and paying the consequences when we screwed up. If you can't get behind that, then just don't do it at all. There are dues to pay, no matter what you may learn on the imperfect Internet. Just learn to solder correctly. |
Author: | dzsmith [ Tue Jan 21, 2014 7:09 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
I don't think I stated that I don't know how to solder. I've been soldering electronic components for 40 years. I don't want to risk melting the plastic by applying heat to the eyelets. I'm going to splice the wires. And I will cover the splices with heat shrink. I will use single wires rather than shielded cable. My query has been answered. Dan |
Author: | theguitarwhisperer [ Wed Jan 22, 2014 9:19 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Strat pickups - wires too short |
He wasn't asking about how to solder, he was wondering if it would be worth it to attach a shielded cable to the pickup, or if he should simply lengthen the leads a little. It doesn't really seem like you guys are reading the posts before you type. |
Page 1 of 2 | All times are UTC - 5 hours |
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |